Notice that you can even use plain water to substitute for beef broth, adding a little butter or oil will with the water will mimic the fat in beef broth. It will give you the flavor boost you’re seeking. Vegetable broth is an easy trade-in any recipe, however, something like seafood broth may not be compatible with all flavors. It will change the flavor profile as the spices and herbs you use will be a bit muted by the stronger beef broth. Beef stock has a distinctive flavor that will enhance highly flavored stews or braised meats, while chicken has a milder, less intense flavor. Chicken Broth Substitutes.

If all you are making is the rice the beef broth would be alright. Its depth of flavor can truly make or break a meal. For example, vegetable broth is a little less of a substitute for beef or chicken broth than beef is for chicken and vice versa because of the fat contents in meat-based broths. Otherwise, grab your favorite chicken broth at the store and use it in all of your favorite recipes from now on. You probably should use beef broth.

Chowhounds have several explanations. It depends on how you're using either in a recipe.

If you can't make your own, however, and absolutely must have a beef flavor for your dish, López-Alt recommends you use Better Than Bouillon Beef Base instead of store-bought beef broth. I think the beef broth would be a bit strong. If you need a chicken broth substitute, you can use the same amount of white wine or a combination of water with 1 tablespoon of olive oil or melted butter. Very rarely. Chicken Broth Substitutes. Homemade broth also delivers certain health benefits, such as reducing cold and flu symptoms, improving bone health, and acting as …

Healthy Broth Substitute Canned broths and bouillon cubes are usually saltier than homemade stocks.

Homemade chicken broth -- golden yellow and fragrant with chicken, onions, celery, carrots and sage -- can't be beat for recipes. Chicken broth is flavorful and nutritious and can be used to cook rice or other grains, as a base for soups or curries, or to make dumplings or stuffing.

Sometimes you don't have the time to make it, just need a cupful for a recipe or have run out of your stock supply in the freezer. Given its importance in a recipe, knowing the best chicken broth substitutes is … Beef Stew normally has cooked vegetables and beef broth is a dark clear liquid. Chicken broth is undeniably a surefire way of enhancing the body or flavor of your favorite dish―be it chicken noodle soup or any rice recipe with chicken dumplings. You can purchase beef broth in stores or make it yourself by boiling beef in water.

The answer is, it all depends.